Letters

June 1, 2002

RE "PUBCO hope to spread across province," (May 22):

The PUBCO story paints all the misconceptions that both PUBCO and the tobacco industry (presumably a strong PUBCO supporter) would have us believe.

Ottawa is no guinea pig. The same smoke free legislation has swept through much of the United States, first at the municipal level and later at the state level. The tobacco industry fears the municipal level since it is at this level that local citizens get up and speak before municipal councils, get out and organize and protect their own environment.

The level playing field will happen when enough municipalities have gone smoke free i.e. there is consensus. Ottawa will serve as an excellent example of a bylaw that has worked and stuck. The Ottawa bylaw has had strong support and a lot of people are now delighted to either visit or work in a smoke free environment.

Smoke free makes it easier to quit and normalizes a smoke-free country. It denormalizes tobacco in general. Second-hand smoke kills normal people, smokers and non-smokers alike, through heart disease and lung cancer. It makes children sick and adults with lung disease are often affected by very short exposure. The rules are about protecting the public who frequent these establishments and the workers who work in them.

The main risk here is to the tobacco industry which stands to lose big over time, but which has always excelled at having someone else do their dirty work. PUBCO appears to be deeply immersed in the dirt. The main benefit is health and clean air to all of us. Ottawa is a much better town for this bylaw.

David S. Esdaile MD
Vice-President, Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada